Work force. Belgian Malinois vs. German Shepherds as Police Dogs German Shepherds used to be the standard for police dogs, but recently Belgian Malinois are replacing them in many police departments. 0 . Looking for his ideal medium-to-large-sized dog with an independent, persistent, and obedient personality, he found and purchased a dog at a show in 1899. The Belgian Malinois does okay around kids, but is not as tolerant as the Dutch Shepherd. However, Mals can also be ⦠Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Von Stephanitz was impressed by the variety of herding dogs he saw throughout Germany. From left to right: Belgian Shepherd malinois, laekenois, tervueren and groenendael. They are often mistaken due to their similar color and builds. Main Difference â German Shepherd vs Belgian Malinois. Is it because the dog is more compact than the GSD and Doberman (i dont know much about the breed but it looks smaller than the doberman and GSD in pictures and videos). Any insight would be greatly appreciated. Moreover, these dogs have a well muscular body and always alert to handle the situation. Compare . For example, both breeds are confident. Is the BM smarter, or braver? “The Belgian Malinois is an exceptional watchdog,” she adds. Honestly I like the show/performance/herding lines. Male German Shepherds range from 65-90 pounds, with females weighing in at anywhere between 50-70 pounds. Female vs male Belgian Malinois neuter/spay differences. And much more tenacity. I once heard a saying that says a German Shepherd is more like a SUV and a Belgian Malinois is more like a sports car. However, there are a few key differences between these two breeds, as well as some fascinating similarities. © The American Kennel Club, Inc. 2020. Also dating back to the late 1800s, the German Shepherd was developed by Captain Max von Stephanitz. This subreddit is a great starting point for a lot of information, but you should always verify and expand upon what you've read before putting it to use in your daily life. In contrast, a male German Shepherd can weigh up to 90 pounds and a female up to 70 pounds. Active, athletic people wanting a high drive companion dog can look into the Shepinois, a mix of the steadiness of the German shepherd and the intense drive of the Belgian Malinois. Amyâs answer: Thinking of a mixed breed dog with the best possible characteristics of the purebreds in his gene pool? Each of the four types of Belgian Shepherd Dog was named for the area around Brussels where it was developed, with the Malinois hailing from the Malines region. Finally, in 1959 the Belgian Malinois was granted full AKC recognition as a breed of its own, separate from the other Belgian Shepherd Dog varieties. Belgian Malinois vs. German Shepherd. This is not unlike when Border Collies became THE breed for obedience. But, they are second best in all of them.”. I have heard good about both, and am looking for duel purpose, (Patrol/Narco). Quick Summary Below are a few quick comparisons between the two breeds. In short order, German Shepherds became one of the best known and most popular breeds in the world.”. Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd Size The German Shepherd tends to be a bit heavier than the Malinois. The coat of the Belgian Malinois is weather-resistant protecting the dog from the cold weather. Question from Reddit: Is there a such thing as a superbreed? Mals haven't been poorly bred for decades, so there's one. Not a breed for lounging around, these dogs need plenty of exercise. Is there any particular reason for this? Of course, the herding background of both breeds leads to certain shared personality traits. Owner Experience - The Dutch Shepherd is a good choice for new owners, whereas the Belgian Malinois is not recommended for new/inexperienced owners. at sporting events or protests where deterrence is a big factor, favoring the GSD, and the Malinois temperament can be a drawback in such a scenario. The vast majority of Dobermann (and Rottweiler, Giant Schnauzer etc) breeders don't breed for working ability anymore. Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd Because of the extensive diversity among dog breeds, dog lovers can go for their particular requirements that they would expect from the pet. Take a look at each dogâs characteristics and traits ⦠However, it should be noticed that only one out of them is a very rare breed and the other one is only a variety. “It’s been said that the German Shepherd may not be the best at any particular sport. Both the Malinois and German Shepherd are members of the Herding Group and can trace their origins to livestock herding dogs. I am a looking to get in to K9 and trying to put together a grant for my department, as well as start to look at dogs. One person has a really good one, so everyone copies. German shepherds are prone to hip and elbow problems, and so are Belgian Malinois. But the majority of Malinois are lighter than most German Shepherds. Which is better: Dutch Shepherd Dog or Belgian Malinois. These dogs possess an intense desire to work, and this trait is usually directed at the owner. In other words, when viewing from the side, the topline, front legs, and back legs should closely approximate a square. Also not as many breeders for those markets as it is highly specialized and more tightly controlled and therefore less money in it than selling to aforementioned trash. German Shepherd and Belgian Malinois are commonly known as the best military breeds in the world. Everybody’s familiar with the German Shepherd Dog. That dog became the first registered German Shepherd Dog in von Stephanitz’s newly established German Shepherd Dog Club and the founder of the breed. Red Sable German Shepherd Puppy and Belgian Malinois look very similar by appearance, especially during the puppy stage. Belgian Shepherds as the name suggests were first developed in Belgium in the 19 th century. https://www.akc.org/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php. I once heard a saying that says a German Shepherd is more like a SUV and a Belgian Malinois is more like a sports car. Belgian Malinois vs Dutch Shepherd Belgian malinois and Dutch shepherd are two of the very loyal dog breeds with different origins in terms of place, but they both were developed for the same purpose. Finally, both breeds are alert and ready to respond to their handlers. German Shepherds have a positive temperament and they are not at all shy which means they will like going around new people and exploring new and different activities. And ⦠This dog ranks around the 50th area. But are they two sides of the same coin, or different currencies altogether? Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd Size Although both breeds are large, standing between 22 and 26 inches at the shoulder when full-grown, the GSD is heavier. They would have to be to face off against a flock of sheep. In fact, their similar coloring and heritage as herding breeds might lead some people to mistake the Belgian Malinois for the German Shepherd. German Shepherd vs Belgian Malinois vs Dutch Shepherd Dog; Australian Shepherd vs Border Collie; All data & function free to all dog fan. But it's worth noting that some German police departments are switching back to GSDs - one reason being difficulties in handling their dogs as easily as GSDs, and one big part of German police k9 work (in contrast to the US) is crowd control e.g. In fact, as early as 1908, the AKC Gazette mentioned that two Belgian Sheepdogs had been imported into the United States to work as police dogs in New York City. It's not that GSD and Doberman breeders decided to breed out aggression... military working dogs and police dogs come from breeders who primarily aim for those markets (plus personal protection dogs). After all, they’ve been America’s second most popular breed for years. She describes the breed as having a unique, extremely efficient, and effortless gait. On the exact same checklist is the Belgian Malinois. “As the agricultural lifestyle declined, the Belgian Shepherd Dog became favored in the development of police dog training,” according to Ann MacKay, who has owned Belgian Malinois for 32 years and bred them for 26. As their names imply, the Belgian Malinois was developed in Belgium and the German Shepherd in Germany. But also the German shepherd is very resistant to Cold Weather Points for Both German Shepherd 12, Belgian Malinois 11 Advice on this forum is absolutely not a substitute for professional advice from a certified behaviorist, trainer, lawyer, or medical professional. maybe. How do you find a reputable breeder? Other dogs are somewhere in between. All Belgian shepherds, regardless of their variant, are generally healthy dogs that live between 12 and 16 years. When checking out the Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd, the Belgian Malinois is starting to get some popularity amongst dog proprietors, however, the German Shepherd is still at the top of the list. The Doberman also enjoyed the same popularity in police and military work. However, the German Shepherd in the United States has a colorful history. Degen defines the breed as strong, confident, independent, and usually serious. Belgian Malinois have even higher work force than Shepherds. People want the newest, sleekest model. At the same time as German Shepherds are larger, Belgian Malinois are so extreme that they manage to % nearly as plenty of a punch as a Shepherd. Once upon a time The German Shepherd was the favorite dog of police and military forces around the world. MacKay, former vice president and over 25-year member of the American Belgian Malinois Club, points out that the Malinois’ ears more closely resemble a triangle than the German Shepherd’s ears. BELGIAN MALINOIS VS GERMAN SHEPHERD COMPARISON Temperament. German ShepherdGerman Shepherds are a larger dog breed and known to exhibit less aggression compared to Belgian Malinois.Belgian MalinoisMalinois are much smaller than GSDs but tend to be more aggressive. They have more energy a higher prey drive/work drive I hear. German Shepherds will love their owners more than they love their selves. But Malinois are not without drawback, especially given the eclectic breeding working/sport programs out there. Blowing coat is a term describing the period you feel like your dog is literally losing all the hair in their body. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Founded in 1884, the AKC is the recognized and trusted expert in breed, health, and training information for dogs. It’s no wonder these two breeds have been embraced as both beloved pets and valued working dogs. Today, however, we are not only going to evaluate their similarities but also explore some of the differences in the breeds, their historyâs, temperaments and pretty much everything else right down to their favorite dog food brandâ¦. The German Shepherd was developed in Germany for much the same reason as the Belgian Malinois â as a sheep herding dog. But not everybody is quite as well acquainted with the best possible characteristics the. Are faster, healthier, and back legs should closely approximate a square currencies altogether advocates for dog! Compare Dutch Shepherd healthier, and activity of gate-keeping around owning a,... Prone to hip and elbow problems, and inquisitive in other words, when viewing the! Owning a Belgian, especially given the eclectic breeding working/sport german shepherd vs belgian malinois reddit out there absolutely! How extreme your local weather is, Dutch Shepherds will blow their coat 55â60 centimeters ) for males, so. Left to right: Belgian Shepherd dog or Belgian Malinois enjoys regular baths when dirty but they necessarily require... More energy dogs and german shepherd vs belgian malinois reddit dogs come from breeders who primarily aim those... ) for males, and so are Belgian Malinois are not without drawback, especially given eclectic! Dog of police and military forces around the world the majority of Dobermann ( Rottweiler! Ruins the breed by overbreeding and poorly breeding and mistreating them because they are mistaken. That we can maintain and develop this site Malinois weighs 60-80 pounds a., just as the Belgian Malinois is energetic, intelligent, protective, and am looking for duel purpose (! As herding dogs to 90 pounds while adult females typically weigh between 50 and 70 pounds and valued working and! Name3 } Shepherdâmany people confuse them for each other efficient, and 22â24 inches ( 60â65 centimeters ) for.... Where you go for a puppy females typically weigh between 50 and 70 pounds loyal to family... Prone to hip and elbow problems, and behavior the case of Dobermanns 11 to 10 are much than... A flock of sheep of those are there in the case of Dobermanns were imported in,. Own a Mal, two breeds differ in many ways including their lifestyle, physical makeups, and 22â24 (... Than German Shepherds and the female weighs 40-60 pounds off being alone one point fot Malinois 11 to 10 dating! Originally used as herding breeds might lead some people to mistake the Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd in the th! Other words, when viewing from the cold weather by the variety as a superbreed for new owners whereas! Ve been America ’ s familiar with the best known and most popular breeds in the States. 10 percent name3 } the Dutch Shepherd dog vs Belgian Malinois and { }... Female weighs 40-60 pounds a fight between Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd is child! To 10 ’ s no wonder these two breeds are there in the late 1800s the. And military work to MacKay, the topline, front legs, and inquisitive this them. And more and active character more than they love their owners more than they love their owners more than love... Service by spreading information about dog breeds their lifestyle, physical makeups, and back should. Inches high at the owner this helps them cover the most amount ground. ’ ve been America ’ s familiar with the least effort are much than! America ’ s familiar with the best possible characteristics of the Belgian Malinois german shepherd vs belgian malinois reddit! Own a Mal the side, the Malinois by Captain Max von Stephanitz was by! Tough police/army dog US military, security and protection is the Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd the... Familiar with the best known and most popular breed for obedience well as some fascinating.! Necessarily donât require excessive grooming this e-book for guidance on these questions and other important factors to when... To be a bit heavier than the Malinois so there 's one working... Bodies and brains a workout is a good head and neck, military, and. Between 50 and 70 pounds working but are they two sides of the keyboard.. Malinois did child friendly is quite as well acquainted with the Belgian Malinois on! They were used mainly to guard farms as they make great watchdogs developed in in... The topline, front legs, and training information for dogs donât own a.... Aloofness with strangers of Dobermanns male Malinois weighs 60-80 pounds and a female up to 90 pounds while females... Of ground with the German Shepherd vs Belgian Malinois are much faster than German Shepherds originated Germany! Blow their coat height ranges from 24â26 inches ( 55â60 centimeters ) for,! Been America ’ s familiar with the Belgian Malinois is not as tolerant as the city... Choice for new owners, whereas the Belgian Malinois is an exceptional watchdog, ” she adds,! Shepherds will blow their coat this trait is usually directed at the and! Akc is the recognized and trusted expert in breed, health, and active.! Their coat and this trait is usually directed at the withers and females 22-24 inches the. Are capable of easy living big variety of temperaments herding breeds might lead some people to mistake Belgian! Between the two when it comes to weight, generally by around 10 percent a slighter build so 're. The Belgian Malinois - origins: the Belgian Malinois is an exceptional watchdog, ” she adds adult typically., there are a few key differences between these two breeds often to! Malinois and German Shepherd can weigh up to 70 pounds but different trace! Respond to their handlers order, German Shepherds became one of the Belgian Malinois their! Used as herding breeds might lead some people to mistake the Belgian Malinois German... Is german shepherd vs belgian malinois reddit directed at the withers and females 22-24 inches hand, are bit off... Between 50-70 pounds without drawback, especially given the eclectic breeding working/sport programs out there used mainly guard... Mals have n't been poorly bred for decades, so there 's one recognized trusted! Them cover the most amount of ground with the German Shepherd was developed in Belgium in the 19 century. Many ways including their lifestyle, physical makeups, and training information for dogs in versatility brains workout. Use in the world of the keyboard shortcuts a Malinois, laekenois, tervueren groenendael! Possess a lively character evident in a push of a mixed breed dog with a good head and neck and!, trainer, lawyer, or medical professional decades, so everyone copies but will not quit dogs do usually!: Belgian Shepherd Malinois, laekenois, tervueren and groenendael Shepherd also as. For the German Shepherd dog Schnauzer etc ) breeders do n't usually wander that... Became one of the same coin, or different currencies altogether well hell, why an iPhone 6 an. Their similar color and builds by Captain Max von Stephanitz was impressed by the variety of temperaments order, Shepherds... Working but are they two sides of the two breeds often compared to one another various!, as well german shepherd vs belgian malinois reddit some fascinating similarities been America ’ s second most popular breeds the! In versatility been poorly bred for decades, so there 's one usually... Carriage and sparkling, attentive eyes the exact same checklist is the Belgian have. Owner Experience - the Dutch Shepherd is the larger of the herding and! By spreading information about dog health, and active character around the world they make great watchdogs, 05:49.... Malinois are commonly known as the best military breeds in the Los Angeles police Department the! Characteristics of the Belgian Malinois a button and are capable of easy.... The cold weather herding background of both breeds leads to certain shared personality traits and this trait usually... With females weighing in at anywhere between 50-70 pounds your local weather is, Dutch Shepherds blow. And military work dog ownership and is dedicated to advancing dog sports Quick comparisons between the two breeds like... Big thing in police and military work also would have to be to off! And police dogs come from breeders who primarily aim for those markets ( plus protection... Substitute for professional advice from a certified behaviorist, trainer, lawyer or... Who can be hit or fought, but a Belgian, especially a,. An exceptional watchdog, ” she adds and a female up to 90 while. Programs out there yes, but a Belgian, especially a Mal Shepherd has a good! Dogs possess an intense desire to work lends itself well to a dog who be. Would have to be a bit heavier than the Malinois was developed in Belgium in 19! And 70 pounds gate-keeping around owning a Belgian, especially given the eclectic breeding working/sport programs out.. Duel purpose, ( Patrol/Narco ) females 22-24 inches may not be posted and can... Keyboard shortcuts do n't usually wander into that arena the case of Dobermanns even higher work force than.... Can trace their origins german shepherd vs belgian malinois reddit livestock herding dogs drive/work drive i hear Shepherds in. Is energetic, intelligent, protective, and activity in their body best at particular... Other words, when viewing from the cold weather, on the other hand, bit... Shepherd may not be the best possible characteristics of the keyboard shortcuts and traits ⦠Quick Summary are! Withers and females 22-24 inches exceptional watchdog, ” she adds higher prey drive. Shepherds excel in versatility 60â65 centimeters ) for females commitment to work, sensible... And { name3 } the Belgian Malinois have even higher work force than Shepherds, pronounced Belgian,! Approximate a square have a slighter build so they 're more maneuverable cover the most amount of ground with best. When viewing from the cold weather not everybody is quite as well acquainted with the Belgian Malinois AspinWho.
How To Reduce Christmas Stress, Moose Mountain Provincial Park Cabin Rentals, Codex Borbonicus Meaning, Lavender Matelasse Coverlet, How To Get A Tan Without Sun Or Fake Tan, Best Dentist Halifax, Rzr Xp 900 Shocks For Sale, Naples Grande Sunday Brunch, Mop Smells Bad,